As people get stirred up over the Newsweek article of last week about the alleged flushing of the Korean at the Gitmo Detention Center, I think it is important to remember that while many in the Islamic world are outraged over this story and the level of violence that it has sparked, I feel it cannot be placed solely at Newsweek's feet. What has occurred is a global erosion of US prestige in the world. These riots are a result of a long series of wrong steps in both the media and the government. This one story, in and of itself isn't the cause. Those in that part of the world believe that we would do such an act. The facts to them are of no relevance. They see it as a part of a greater pattern of our actions. We have failed to counter the propaganda of the Jihadist in that part of the world. And our actions in Iraq have only fed into their point of view.
Now we have the US government asking for a retraction. Rightfully so, but the damage has been done and those who would believe this type of story will not believe a retraction. I get back to the the point that this is endemic of a greater problem. US credibility. People around the world used to believe the statements of the US government on the world stage. Now they look for the "Wag the Dog" effect in almost every word uttered. This is very damaging to the US.
Newsweek should have been more careful about it's stories. In this new world of global communications words have true power on the world. We have known this for some time, but have not seen this type of reaction to a news article printed in this country having such an immediate reaction in a place on the other side of the world viewed as cut off from the main stream of world opinion.
Related Articles:
White House Wants Retraction From Newsweek
Newsweek says Koran desecration report is wrong
Monday, May 16, 2005
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Article from 2003 - Newsweek wasn't wrong...
Afghan prisoners 'shackled, hit, humiliated'
March 27 2003
By Marc Kaufman, April Witt
Kabul
Afghan men freed on Tuesday after spending months in legal limbo as United States prisoners in the war on terrorism said that they were generally well fed and given medical care, but they were housed in cramped cells and sometimes shackled, hit and humiliated.
After a chaotic day in which it was uncertain when, or if, all the prisoners would be released from Afghan custody, 18 men wearing new American sneakers and carrying colourful gym bags walked out of a run-down police compound in Kabul. Some hugged jubilantly; others left feeling bitter and vengeful.
The men, the largest single group of Afghans to be released after months at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, gave varying accounts of how US forces treated them during interrogation and detainment. Some flashed medical records showing extensive care by US military doctors, while others complained that US soldiers insulted Islam by sitting on the Koran or dumping their sacred text into a toilet to taunt them.
Only one prisoner was met by his family. Most of the men are from distant southern or eastern provinces and there were no relatives to meet them, as there had been no time to notify them. Neither the Afghan authorities nor the US officials had given them any money, they said.
"We have no relatives here and no money to get home," said Sher Ghulab, 30, a labourer from the eastern province of Jalalabad.
The men uniformly said that American forces treated them more roughly during initial interrogation and captivity in Afghanistan than during the detainment at Guantanamo.
All of those released said they were not terrorists. Some acknowledged that they had fought with the Taliban, but not by choice. Others said that US forces snatched them away from ordinary lives as farmers, students or taxi drivers.
Sarajudim, 24, who like many Afghans uses only one name, was one of several men who said they were forced to fight with the Taliban after the US declared war on terrorism. Prisoner Merza Khan said that Americans in Kandahar tied him up and alternately forced him to lie face down on the ground, then squat with his hands on his head for hours.
Sulaiman Shah said he was a businessman captured for no reason in northern Afghanistan. "I was in such a small (cell) and couldn't go outside for many days," he said. "My toilet was next to my bed, and it was a very bad way to live."
The US military is investigating the deaths of two Afghan prisoners interrogated at a US military centre at Bagram air base north of Kabul. A military doctor had listed the two deaths as homicides.
- Washington Post, New York Times
Post a Comment